House Speaker Kevin McCarthy’s public message about the Republicans’ debt ceiling crisis is an embarrassing mess. The GOP leader spent yesterday suggesting, for example, that his party was being “responsible“ by approving a ridiculous hostage note that everyone involved in the process knows Democrats will reject.
McCarthy also told Punchbowl News, “We’ve done our job,” which might be more compelling if the House speaker’s job entailed threatening Americans with a deliberate economic catastrophe.
But as woeful as the Republican’s public rhetoric has been, his private messages are likely to be an even bigger problem.
Consider, for example, this New York Times report on what McCarthy told his members to help get his right-wing Limit, Save, Grow Act across the finish line.
Beseeching his colleagues privately to back the bill, Mr. McCarthy repeatedly told them to ignore the substance of the measure, which would never become law, and instead focus on the symbolic victory of passing any legislation to show Mr. Biden they were serious about their demand for spending cuts.
The rationale behind such a message makes some sense: McCarthy made no secret of the fact that he “simply wanted to get to the negotiating table” with Democratic leaders. In order to make that happen, the House needed to pass something.
With this in mind, it’s easy to imagine the speaker effectively telling GOP skeptics from competitive congressional districts, “Don’t worry too much about the details of the bill. This will just open the door to bipartisan talks. You can vote for it now, knowing that the plan will inevitably change.”
There are some risks for the members who are now on the hook for supporting a radical package, but I understand the broader point: McCarthy told concerned House Republicans to ignore the substance of the plan and focus on advancing the process. Those members bought the line.
The trouble is, the speaker delivered a very different kind of message to a…
Read the full article here